| Commit message (Collapse) | Author | Age | Files | Lines |
|---|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
Extends the preface comparison (RG 482-499) with a third, independent
publisher, extraordinaryform.org's three annual Ordo editions
(2024-2025, 2025-2026, 2026-2027), previously declined for two reasons
that are now resolved:
- "Advent" is not a preface: RG 494(b) grants the Trinity preface on
every Advent SUNDAY, RG 498 the residual Common on every Advent
FERIA; this source's own "Advent" label covers both indiscriminately
(confirmed live on all 11 non-impeded Advent Sundays in the corpus).
Classified by the day's own civil weekday, not a static table.
- The known Vigil-of-St-Lawrence gap is reconfirmed, with a nuance not
present in the earlier audits: colitur's own RG33-third-trigger now
omits the vigil in some years too, so the corpus's gap and colitur's
answer coincide in 2025 (a full match, not a coincidence) while 2027
still shows the classic identity-wrong-but-preface-invisible shape.
Re-derives the known menu-trap office filter (Requiem-skip, "and "-chain)
against the live JSON and finds a second, general pattern: "Saturday of
Our Lady" (RG78's BVM Saturday Office), whenever listed, is
unconditionally the office -- checked exhaustively across all 38
instances in the corpus, zero counter-examples. A third, generic
"absorption" rule was deliberately not built: it would resolve 2 of the
11 residual divergences but wrongly misfires on a structurally identical
but semantically different shape (an optional Rogation-day Mass option).
The JSON's own extraction carries a genuine classifier gap: parse_ordo.py's
hardcoded PREFACES set omits "Christ the King", misfiling it into comms;
recovered in the generator, not left blank.
11 of 1088 comparable rows diverge, resolving to 7 adjudicated root
causes (E1-E7): two Commemoration_only Marian titles reduced to
commemorations (Mt Carmel, Ransom), two genuine sanctoral data gaps
cross-confirmed absent by the FIUV/LMS witnesses (Miraculous Medal,
St John before the Latin Gate), two single-witnessed efdotorg outliers
against FIUV/LMS agreement (St Michael's Dedication, All Saints on a
Sunday), and one isolated source labelling slip.
Mutation-tested: corrupting the RG495 BVM-Saturday clause reddens 9
tests across this new layer and both existing Ordo witnesses.
Per-edition agreement: 358/363 (2024-2025), 358/363 (2025-2026),
361/362 (2026-2027).
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
Extends tools/extract_lms_ordo.ml's row type with a praef field (the
first "Pr of ..." / "Common Pr" match in each day's universal block,
same first-in-reading-order discipline already used for Gl/Cr) and
regenerates all three LMS fixtures. Also brings lms-ordo-2024-2025.sexp
under the generalised, probe-verified provenance template the Witnesses
task previously added only for the two newer editions -- it had kept
Task 6's original hand-written header.
Characterisation finding: this Ordo prints OPTION LISTS ("Pr of X or Pr
of Y or Common Pr"), not a single value per day, and several named
options (Martyrs, All Saints and Patron Saints, the Dedication of a
Church, the Most Holy Sacrament, St John the Baptist, the Angels) are
genuinely absent from RG 484-497's own fourteen named prefaces. Every
instance found in the universal block pairs such an extra with a
genuine RG-482 answer, so test/test_lms_ordo.ml compares by membership
(classify_praef_options, a 15-entry prefix table split on the
standalone token "or"), not string equality.
Opposite-prediction probes (Nativity/Apostles/Requiem) are hard-
verified inside the extractor itself before any fixture is trusted, the
same discipline already used for the Creed column.
Result: 396/396, 399/399, 398/398 comparable rows agree across the
three editions (Good Friday excluded per edition, no Mass that day),
zero allow-list entries needed.
extraordinaryform.org's own three editions were characterised but
deliberately not wired in this pass -- see
.superpowers/sdd/2026-08-21-colitur-celebrant-rubrics-phase1/preface-witnesses-report.md
for the full account (the field is genuinely per-day, contrary to a
naive header-count read, but carries its own classification anomaly
during Advent and reconfirms the corpus's known St Lawrence vigil
defect, and building a full extractor for it is a separate, comparably
large task not needed to decide the RG 497 question this same report
settles).
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_017ZBxCCRM2ojnBupp3SBxV9
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
data/ef/expected-divergences-lms.sexp's L5 (16 dates, LMS Ordo Gloria=true
vs colitur's false) and data/ef/expected-divergences-fiuv.sexp's F3 (6
dates, FIUV Te Deum=true vs colitur's false) were both misadjudicated as
colitur's own gap under an RG 302(b)/431(b) hypothesis. Both are wrong.
These are occurrence differences from the 2020 decree Cum Sanctissima,
which colitur excludes from its 1962 core by binding design (CLAUDE.md
decision 2). RG 303(b) ("dici potest tantum si occurrit dies liturgicus IV
classis") already prohibits 302(b) on the Class3 privileged ferias both
entries cover -- the original text quoted 303(b) but never followed it to
its conclusion. Decisively, the FIUV Ordo prints BOTH readings on the six
shared dates, separated by a literal "-VEL-" token: the primary, strict-
1962 reading (feria wins, sine Gloria, no Te Deum) matches colitur exactly;
the second, Cum-Sanctissima reading (saint kept, Gloria, Te Deum) matches
the LMS Ordo exactly.
F3 itself was never a real Te Deum finding: tools/extract_fiuv_ordo.ml's
extract_te_deum scanned each block unbounded for "Ad Mat.", so on these six
days -- whose primary office states no "Ad Mat." of its own -- it silently
read the second office's own Te Deum instead. Fixed with a new
split_at_alt_office, cutting every block at "-VEL-" before any field
extraction runs; the alternative is captured, not discarded, in a new
alt_te_deum field. A hard characterisation probe asserts the split fires on
exactly the six known dates.
Auditing for the same trap elsewhere (this is the third such manufactured
divergence in this project) found a related but narrower marker, "Vel (sec.
decretum <<Cum sanct.>>) Missa ...", offering an alternate Mass formulary
within a single office. It never corrupted Gloria/Credo (always stated
before the marker on all 20 real instances, confirmed by diff), only the
uncompared praef field; hardened defensively anyway, before it could ever
fire live. The LMS Ordo (all three editions) carries no equivalent
dual-print mechanism at all. expected-divergences-missalemeum.sexp's M27
is the same genus but was already correctly adjudicated, not touched.
Both allow-list entries are rewritten, not deleted: the original SHAPE/
CITATION/WHY-NOT-FIXED-HERE reasoning is preserved verbatim as a recorded,
superseded hypothesis, matching this project's own correction convention.
test_lms_ordo.ml's matching predicate is unchanged (the 16-date population
still fires, and always will, because it reflects a standing exclusion,
not a bug); only its citation comment is corrected. test_fiuv_ordo.ml's
F3-specific predicate/count assertion is removed, matching this file's own
prior F2/F4 closure discipline.
lib/ is untouched. dune test: 676/676. make check
(COLITUR_EXHAUSTIVE_SWEEP=1, full 1583-9999 domain): 678/678.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
Phase 2 of celebrant-rubrics-phase1: colitur rubrics gains a fifth
column, whether the Gloria is said. Follows the Creed's own seam
exactly -- Rite.t.gloria, Liturgical_day.t.gloria, wired through
calendar.ml the same way.
RG 431(a)/432(a) defer the Gloria to the Breviary's own Te Deum rule
(nn. 237-238), so te_deum is implemented as its own named predicate,
cited clause by clause, not collapsed into a colour heuristic. 431(c)
(Holy Thursday, the Easter Vigil Mass) and 432(b)/(d) (violet; a
Requiem) are independent overrides checked ahead of the Te Deum-derived
answer. Every clause this engine has no dimension to model
(votive Mass classes, the wider n.302 "Missa festiva" categories) is
stated as N/A with its own reasoning, not silently dropped.
Validated against the FIUV universal Ordo (Gloria and Te Deum) and all
three LMS editions (Gloria). A first pass over-trusted a clean-looking
15-for-15 FIUV contradiction of 237(b)'s own Septuagesima exception and
replaced it with a blanket "every Sunday" rule; the evidence was itself
corrupted -- the FIUV extractor recognised only one of the source's two
Te Deum negations ("non dicitur", not "sine"), so every "sine Te Deum"
Sunday read wrongly true. Fixed in tools/extract_fiuv_ordo.ml, fixture
re-extracted, and the literal 237(b) reading restored once the
corrected data confirmed it. A second bug surfaced alongside it (Palm/
Passion Sunday wrongly reading true via Temporal_ef.named's own table
membership, then Christ the King wrongly reading false from an
over-broad fix) is closed with an explicit two-slug exclusion.
Domain-wide 1583-9999: every violet or Rose day is gloria=false except
the Easter Vigil (RG 431(c) lex specialis), every Requiem is
gloria=false, both measured exhaustively, zero exceptions. Mutation-
proved: disabling 431(c) reddens 8 tests including all four oracle
comparisons; disabling 238(c)'s feria-I-classis exclusion reddens
exactly the dedicated Ash Wednesday unit test, a genuine blind spot in
both oracle layers, reported rather than hidden.
Two open, cited findings, neither fixed here (out of this task's
"follow creed's exact seam" scope): a privileged Lenten/Passiontide
feria carrying one commemoration reads Gloria=true in the LMS Ordo but
Te-Deum=true/Gloria=false in FIUV -- the two oracles disagree with each
other, not merely with colitur (data/ef/expected-divergences-lms.sexp
L5, expected-divergences-fiuv.sexp F3); and a pre-existing, uncited
Colour.Violet bug on Rogation Monday/Tuesday in Temporal_ef.temporal,
surfaced by this comparison but root-caused as a separate defect (L6).
day/readings verified byte-identical against a build from the branch
tip before this task (v0.10.1's own tag predates an already-landed
bissextile fix that legitimately changed both, so it is not the right
baseline).
671 tests green (dune test); 678 with the exhaustive sweep
(COLITUR_EXHAUSTIVE_SWEEP=1 dune test --force, ~104s).
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
Wires in the FIUV (Foederatio Internationalis Una Voce) Ordo for
2025-2026 as validation layer seven -- the first UNIVERSAL (not
diocesan) source in this project, and the first compiled by someone
other than the LMS editions' own Peter Day-Milne (Joseph Shaw, FIUV
President).
tools/extract_fiuv_ordo.ml hand-parses pdftotext's -layout dump of the
Latin-language ordo (no Str/regex, frozen deps). Three real parsing
traps were found and fixed by tracing actual false results against the
raw source, not assumed in advance:
- "Gloria" is also the first word of "Gloria Patri" (the psalm
doxology), which can appear INSIDE the very Mass clause being scanned
(Good Friday: "...omittuntur ps. Iudica me et Gloria Patri), Gloria,
sine Credo..."). Guarded by rejecting any "Gloria" hit whose next
token is "Patri".
- Christmas Day's own rubric uses the PLURAL "Missae"/"Missae" ("tres
Missae celebrantur..."), never the singular "Missa" every other real
day anchors on -- silently produced gloria=None/credo=None on the one
most doctrinally unambiguous day in the calendar until traced and
fixed, guarded in turn against "Missae defunctorum" (an unrelated
Requiem-prohibition notice appearing at the end of many day-blocks).
- The Vespers boundary (bounding the primary Mass option before a
second "Vel Missa" alternative or before Vespers information) missed
the ligature spelling "VESPERÆ", the dominant form in this source,
letting a whole day's trailing prose leak into the captured [praef]
field on the task brief's own worked example day (19 September).
A distinct second stop-marker bug: the malformed trailing entry this
source shares structurally with the LMS PDFs (a stray, mislabelled
duplicate of 1 January) was initially over-matched by a generic
"first token is 4 digits" heuristic, which false-positived on an
indulgence-decree date citation wrapped mid-sentence in October
("...20 augusti / 1885, 26 augusti 1886..."), truncating the extraction
to 308 of 400 real days. Fixed by anchoring on the tail entry's own
distinctive "1st Jan" opening instead.
Five opposite-prediction Creed probes are re-verified by the tool
itself against its own extracted rows (a failed probe is a hard exit,
not a printed claim) before the fixture is written.
test/test_fiuv_ordo.ml compares the Creed against colitur across all
399 comparable days (Holy Saturday excluded, no Mass that day) --
CLEAN, zero unexplained divergences, a genuine second confirmation of
{!Rite_ef.Rubrics_ef.creed} independent of the LMS lineage. [praef],
[te_deum] and [class_] (including the FIUV ordo's own "III cl." vs
"III cl. (Priv.)" Cum Sanctissima convention, stated on its title
page) are captured into the fixture but deliberately not compared --
colitur has no Gloria/preface predicate yet, and its default
configuration models no Cum Sanctissima overlay to compare the class
convention against.
All 634 tests green (dune test), 635 with the exhaustive sweep and
make check. No lib/ file touched.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_017ZBxCCRM2ojnBupp3SBxV9
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
Generalises tools/extract_lms_ordo.ml's start-of-body detection: the
hardcoded "End of November 2024" sentinel assumed every edition opens
with an "End of November" stub section. The 2023-2024 edition has none
(Advent Sunday 2023 fell on 3 December, so the compiler folded the two
tail days into the "December 2023" header directly) -- the generalised
detector anchors on the body's own "ORDO" title line instead, verified
unique in all three known editions and distinct from the Table of
Contents' lowercase "Ordo" entries.
Extracts test/fixtures/lms-ordo-2023-2024.sexp (397 rows) and
lms-ordo-2025-2026.sexp (399 rows), each with a provenance header
carrying its own SHA-256, source citation, and a per-edition
characterisation record: five opposite-prediction Creed probes,
independently re-verified against this run's own extracted rows (a
failed probe is now a hard die, not a printed claim). The 2025-2026
edition needed a different sharp II-class pairing than 2024-2025's
Joachim/Stephen one, because Joachim (16 August) is impeded by a Sunday
that year -- recorded in the fixture header, not silently swapped.
test/test_lms_ordo.ml is refactored into a parameterised make_suite,
instantiated once per edition; every count Task 6 hardcoded against the
single 2024-2025 window is now a per-edition parameter, several of which
turned out to differ once measured (BVM-Saturday population 12/14/13,
Ascension-week exclusion 1/3/2). Two mapping gaps surfaced only by the
new windows and fixed here (test-side, not colitur): Low Sunday reached
via Preceding_sunday for the first time (absent from 2024-2025's own
window), and the Ascension-week exclusion was wrongly keyed off week
number alone -- Rogation Monday also resumes week 6's Sunday but falls
BEFORE Ascension, not after, and the Ordo prints the ordinary Sunday
text there. Re-bounded by date, against Ascension and Pentecost.
Two genuine divergences surfaced in the 2023-2024 window and are
allow-listed (L3, L4) rather than fixed, per this task's no-lib-changes
scope:
- L3 (verdict ordo): colitur has no bissextile calendar rule. The 1962
Missal's own calendarium moves St Matthias from 24 to 25 February in
leap years (docs/research/LT.txt:5011); colitur keeps him on the 24th
every year. Domain-wide upper bound measured with a throwaway sweep:
1,650 of 2,041 leap years in 1583-9999 currently observe him there.
- L4 (verdict open): Christmas Eve falling on the 4th Sunday of Advent
(2023-12-24, roughly 1 year in 7). colitur says the Creed is said,
reading RG 475(a)'s Sunday clause; the Ordo says it is not. RG 30(a)'s
own "locum tenet ... nulla fit commemoratio" for this exact vigil
reads like RG 16(a)'s Feast-of-the-Lord-on-Sunday shape, which colitur
already treats as Creed-preserving -- but RG 475(a) names "festo"
specifically, and a vigil is its own liturgical-day category (RG 35),
so the counter-reading is real too. Left open rather than adjudicated.
All 630 tests green (dune test), 631 with the exhaustive sweep.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_017ZBxCCRM2ojnBupp3SBxV9
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
An independent lineage -- neither Divinum Officium, missalemeum nor
lectio -- covering the Mass formulary and the Creed. Characterised
before use, per the discipline the extraordinaryform.org Ordo's
blanket St Lawrence vigil gap taught this session: five opposite-
prediction Creed probes (Sunday/feria, octave-override vs plain
II-class, I-class) all confirmed against the raw extracted text
before a single divergence was adjudicated, recorded in the
fixture's own provenance header.
tools/extract_lms_ordo.ml hand-parses pdftotext -layout output (no
Str/regex, frozen deps) into test/fixtures/lms-ordo-2024-2025.sexp,
400 day-rows (2024-11-27..2025-12-31). Gl/Cr print per Mass-option,
not per day; the extractor takes the first pair in reading order,
which the source's own layout guarantees is the universal entry's,
since a diocesan variant always follows it, never precedes it. The
Ordo's I-V roman numeral ("Missae de sancta Maria in sabbato", RG
309(a)) is matched whole-line only, never by substring -- "V Mass of
BVM" is a substring of "IV Mass of BVM".
test/test_lms_ordo.ml compares two axes 1:1 by date:
- the Creed (RG 475-476): 399 of 400 days comparable (Good Friday
has no Mass at all, asserted as the only such day); one genuine
divergence, adjudicated to the ORDO, not colitur -- All Souls'
Day 2025-11-03 is a Requiem Mass, and colitur's own creed
predicate has no notion of one, a pre-existing scope gap
rubrics_ef.ml already documented in its own header before this
task existed.
- the BVM-Saturday seasonal Mass selection, the addendum's own
"sharper check": all 14 Votive days in the window match their
season's own numeral exactly, both directions, independently
re-derived from RG 309(a) rather than calling colitur's private
function.
- the formulary override, for the three sources it can honestly
discriminate (Proper 179, Preceding_sunday 66, Common 2, all
clean); Own_slug (139) is excluded with evidence, not silently --
several ferial slugs carry citations byte-identical to their
Sunday's own, so the Ordo's override line cannot distinguish the
two representations.
data/ef/expected-divergences-lms.sexp carries the one adjudicated
entry (L1), cited to RG 476(f).
Mutation-tested: inverting RG 475(a)'s Sunday clause reddens 10
existing Rubrics_ef unit tests AND this new layer's own comparator,
independently, on a data source none of the other five layers touch.
Reverted after confirming.
No lib/ changes. day/readings/rubrics output re-confirmed byte-
identical (1583, 2026, 2038, 9999) after this task; all three gates
green (dune test, exhaustive sweep, make check).
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
lectio adopted the last two Missal corrections colitur argued:
C14 3 -> 0 RG 96(a)/97/98. lectio resolved each impeded I-class feast's
transfer independently, so in 2008, 2035 and 2046 St Joseph and
the Annunciation both walked onto the Monday after Low Sunday
and Joseph, losing there, was observed on no day of those years
at all. It now resolves the year's transfers as a set: the
Annunciation takes the Monday as its sedes propria, Joseph the
Tuesday.
C15 7 -> 0 The Holy Family propers' own 13-January rubric, "sine
commemoratione Baptismatis D.N.I.C.". lectio kept the Baptism
as the observed office on all seven such years in 2005-2050.
Those were the last two BEHAVIOUR classes. What is left is C1 (138) and C6
(119), both pure slug vocabulary.
Measured across the whole fixture, applying only the season normalisation the
test already applies: 579 of 16801 days differ, and every one of them differs
on the SLUG ALONE. Zero days differ on season, rank, colour, Epistle or Gospel.
(The test's own norm_slug table already maps 322 of the 579; the 257 left are
C1 and C6. The field profile is the same either way.)
So the two engines now agree on every liturgically meaningful field on every
day of 2005-2050. The residue is what the two projects call things --
ef-christmas-2-friday against ef-time-after-epiphany-1-friday for the same day,
same Mass. Aligning it means renaming lectio's slugs, and those are keys: its
lectionary, clectio's generated tables and any user overlay are built on them.
Left as vocabulary rather than forced.
Fixture refreshed against lectio e713da2; 13 rows changed, colitur agrees with
all of them. 24 divergence classes at the start of this work, 2 now.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
The ferias between Epiphany and the first Sunday after it repeat Epiphany's
own Mass in lectio now; they had been taking the Mass of the Sunday that
follows them.
C31 98 -> 0
C1 40 -> 138 grew, and changed character
C1 is now SLUG VOCABULARY ONLY, and its note says so. Season, rank, colour and
both citations agree with colitur on every day of the January window; what
differs is the identifier -- ef-christmas-2-thursday against
ef-time-after-epiphany-1-thursday for the same day with the same Mass. C6 is
the same shape.
That is 257 of the 267 remaining rows. Aligning the vocabularies would mean
renaming lectio's slugs, and those are keys: its own lectionary, clectio's
generated tables and any user overlay are built on them. Recorded as
vocabulary rather than closed, because the rows do differ -- just not in
anything a reader of either engine's output sees.
Measured for 2026: season, rank and colour agree on all 365 days; 14 days
differ and every one differs on the slug alone.
5 classes -> 4, agreement 98.4%.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
lectio carries the readings of the nine Common-routed saints and of three more
that had proper Masses but no reading at all. Every day of 2005-2050 now
resolves a reading there; four days used to come back empty.
C38's own note said it could not close without lectio gaining a Commons
concept. The readings arrived instead of the abstraction, which was enough:
each Common resolves to one first/gospel pair for the saint that names it, so
a table plus assignment layer would have bought indirection and nothing else.
C20 14 -> 0
C38 70 -> 0
7 classes -> 5, 351 rows -> 267, agreement 97.9% -> 98.4%.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
lectio gained the Passiontide week split and thirteen lectionary entries.
C23 230 -> 0 Holy Week's own six Masses
C32 99 -> 0
C35 60 -> 0 the first weeks after Epiphany and Pentecost (RG 299)
C33 46 -> 0 Corpus Christi
C34 46 -> 0 the Sacred Heart
C26 43 -> 0 Passion Tuesday
C19 7 -> 0 the Holy Family week-index residue
C1 75 -> 40
C31 63 -> 98 GREW
The Passiontide split is the one that carried most of this. efWeek had no
Passiontide case, so both weeks numbered 0 and every day of Holy Week took the
slug of its Passion-week namesake -- one set of readings for two weeks with
entirely different Masses. Good Friday was reading Passion Friday's.
C31 growing is the same bookkeeping as C1's earlier growth and is recorded in
its own note: C32 and C35 closed, and rows that carried several causes now
carry only this one. Nothing new disagrees.
17 classes -> 10, 1019 rows -> 488, agreement 93.9% -> 97.1%.
What remains is almost entirely NAMING rather than disagreement: C6 (119) is
colitur's ef-nativity-octave-day-N against lectio's ef-christmas-N-weekday on
days where both now read the same Mass, and C1 (40) is the same shape in the
January window.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
lectio gained Rogation Monday and Tuesday (RG 87, violet under RG 128(d)) and
the Missal's own Mass for the weekdays within the Octave of the Nativity
("Diebus infra octavam Nativitatis Domini", Titus 3:4-7 / Luke 2:15-20).
C8 26 -> 0 CLOSED
C6 119 -> 119 narrowed: the cause halved, the count did not
C6 is worth reading carefully rather than skimming the number. Its rows no
longer differ on First_f or Gospel_f at all -- the two engines now read the
SAME Mass on 29-31 December, where lectio previously served the Sunday's. What
is left is Slug_f alone, colitur's ef-nativity-octave-day-N against lectio's
ef-christmas-N-weekday. That is vocabulary, not disagreement. The count did not
move because the entry's gate already admitted a Slug_f-only subset, which is
exactly the case where a row count is a misleading summary.
17 classes, 1019 rows, agreement 93.9%.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
lectio built the votive Office of Our Lady on Saturday (RG 78) and then said
RG 309(a)'s own Mass for it. Both halves were needed: RG 78 keeps the office
and gives it white, RG 309(a) picks among the Missal's five seasonal
formularies. Fixing only the first leaves the day announcing Our Lady and
reading the feria's Mass -- the bug colitur itself shipped briefly and fixed
in its v0.3.0.
C17 439 -> 0 CLOSED -- the largest class between the two engines
C31 103 -> 63 Saturdays that carried both causes; only this one left
C35 69 -> 60 same
C1 35 -> 75 GREW
C1 growing is not a regression and is recorded as such in its own note: the
January Saturdays C17 used to absorb now differ only on the slug vocabulary
C1 already covers, so they land there instead. Rows moved between entries as
the larger cause was removed.
Also in this refresh, from the same session: weeks after Epiphany now count
from the first Sunday after it rather than from 6 January, which took C19
from 35 to 7 -- what remains there is the Holy Family interaction, a different
cause needing RG 17(b) in lectio.
19 classes -> 18, 1493 rows -> 1045, agreement 91.1% -> 93.8%.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
lectio has taken three further corrections colitur argued from the Missal: the
twelve RG 124 colours (red is for Apostles, Evangelists and Martyrs, and
missalemeum had the rule inverted in both directions), Good Friday's black
under RG 128(b) with RG 132, and RG 72's Christmas Time boundary at 13 January
inclusive.
864 rows changed. Two classes closed outright and two moved:
C18 450 -> 0 the RG 124 colours -- the LARGEST single class in this file
C36 46 -> 0 Good Friday's colour
C1 159 -> 35 the season boundary stopped differing
C23 184 -> 230 Good Friday's rows fold back, the split no longer needed
C36 is closed rather than kept at zero because the split it represented has
dissolved: it existed only to hold Good Friday apart while its diff set had a
third member, and with the colour agreeing the rows are the exact pair C23 has
always gated on. Restoring 230 is not a regression, it is the number returning
to what it was before the split.
Cited classes 24 -> 19, divergent rows 2252 -> 1521, agreement 86.6% -> 90.9%.
The percentage is again the least interesting part. C18 alone was 450 days on
which the two engines agreed about nothing and now agree because both apply
RG 124 the same way round.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
Every previous refresh of this fixture carried lectio's answers TO colitur,
because colitur's data was bootstrapped from lectio. This one carries
colitur's answers BACK. lectio has merged eight field corrections colitur
argued from the 1962 Missal: ubaldus and didacus promoted from commemoration
to III-class feast on the Missal's own calendarium, both August vigils
recoloured violet under RG 128, and both Ember Saturdays' readings, which
lectio had carrying St Thomas's and St Matthew's Masses respectively.
227 of the 16801 rows changed. Three cited classes went to zero and are
CLOSED and REMOVED, citations preserved in the register, the same discipline
C2-C5, C7, C9-C13, C21, C22 and C25 already record:
C27 40 -> 0 the Advent Ember Saturday's readings
C28 40 -> 0 the September Ember Saturday's readings
C37 77 -> 0 the two vigil colours
C37 is worth noting by name: its own note called the shared lineage "the
sharpest demonstration in the project", colitur and lectio and missalemeum all
carrying the same two wrong colours. Two of the three now carry the right one.
C38 NARROWED rather than closed, and the distinction matters. Its identity
half is gone -- lectio ranks both saints class-3 now -- but the same 70 rows
still differ on readings, because both saints take their Mass from a Common
and lectio has no Commons concept to resolve one. It is gated on
diffs = [First_f; Gospel_f] exactly, which is C18's shape. It cannot close
without lectio gaining a capability, which is a feature rather than a fix.
Net: 24 cited classes to 21, 2252 divergent rows to 2095, agreement 86.6% to
87.5%. The number that matters is not the percentage though -- it is that
those 227 days now agree BECAUSE BOTH ENGINES FOLLOW THE MISSAL, where before
they agreed because both inherited the same errors from Divinum Officium.
That is the failure mode CLAUDE.md's lineage note describes, resolved rather
than documented, for the first time in this project.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
Step 4's blind spot is now closed as far as the method allows. 2038
witnessed two of the five Common-routed saints; isidore-of-seville is the
third and the last that any year in 2005-2050 can reach, being observed
only in 2008, 2035 and 2046. He is also the only saint routing through
common-of-doctors, so that Common had never been compared against any
external source in any window.
Three independent agreements on it: the scan (Commune Doctorum,
scan1:41878ff, 2 Tim. 4, 1-8 / Mt. 5, 13-19), colitur, and missalemeum's
own 2035-04-04 row. Asserted by date in its own test rather than folded
into an aggregate count, so a regression there cannot hide.
The remaining two saints are unreachable by construction, not for want of
a fixture: gregory-the-great and patrick both sit in March and are
impeded by Lent's privileged ferias in every one of the 46 years the
differential covers. The blind spot is closed to its limit, not closed
absolutely, and the register says so.
The comparator is generalised rather than copied -- compare_live takes a
fixture and a year -- so a fourth window would cost a fixture and a count
list.
2035 differs on 3 days, both families pre-existing and already cited.
2035-04-02/03 are the Joseph/Annunciation transfer pair landing in the
opposite order from missalemeum's: neither stream loses a feast, the
sequence differs, which is C14's own RG 96 collision finally getting an
oracle window. 2035-12-30 is the Sunday within the Christmas Octave
against colitur's numbered octave-day slug, C6's family. Both are
recognised by slug rather than by date, so a year exhibiting only half
the shape would surface as unexplained rather than be quietly absorbed.
393 tests green with the exhaustive sweep.
Register: section 6.15.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
The Overlay algebra has been built and tested since Plan 2, and
Date_spec grew movable variants last commit, but there was still no way
to hand colitur a file: bin/main.ml applied exactly one overlay, the
shipped data/ef/adjustments.sexp, with the path hardcoded. This is the
plumbing.
--overlay is repeatable and ordered, and applies ON TOP of the shipped
adjustments rather than instead of them. That ordering is the whole
point: adjustments.sexp carries RG 110's own 30 June companion, the Major
Litanies, St Barbara and Rogation Wednesday, and a user file that
replaced it would silently drop all four while appearing merely to add a
local feast. Overlay.merge is last-writer-wins, so a local calendar can
still override a universal entry deliberately, by naming its slug.
The dispatch needed real argument parsing. It matched Sys.argv as an
exact array, which does not survive a repeatable flag -- two --overlay
arguments are a different array shape from one, and each further flag
would multiply the patterns again. Flags are now stripped first and the
remaining words matched as command plus year. Hand-rolled, because the
dependency list is frozen and this is fifteen lines. One defect found by
the cram suite on the first run: the unknown-option guard rejected
--help and --version, having excluded only their short forms.
Refused, not ignored, on easter and temporal. Neither reads sanctoral
data -- temporal deliberately runs the cycle before any layer exists --
so accepting the flag there and silently doing nothing is the failure
mode this project refuses everywhere else.
A file that fails to load is fatal, exactly as the shipped overlay is; a
directive naming a slug that does not exist warns on stderr and the run
continues. The second matters more for a user file than for ours: a typo
in a diocesan calendar should say so rather than quietly do nothing.
test/fixtures/overlay-example-diocesan.sexp is a worked example and is
labelled as invented, not calendar data. It carries both shapes a real
local calendar needs: a fixed-date patron, and a dedication on "the first
Sunday of October" -- which is the case the Date_spec work existed to
unlock and which lands on 4 October in 2026, 3 October in 2027, 1 October
in 2028. The dedication is I class because a church's own dedication
anniversary is I class in that church; at III class it lost to the
II-class Sunday every year, which a first draft demonstrated correctly
and uselessly.
The man page gains an OVERLAYS section saying plainly that an overlay is
applied, NOT validated: the five test layers assert things about the
shipped calendar and none of them can vouch for a file the user supplies.
This is the first feature that lets someone change what colitur computes,
and that distinction should not have to be inferred.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
Register section 6.7 recorded that step 4 of the reading chain -- the
Common route -- had no external witness of any kind, and proved it by
mutation: corrupting a Common citation left both the 16801-day
differential and the 730-day oracle green. This closes that.
2038 is the only year in 2005-2050 in which two of the five
Common-routed saints are the observed office (Perpetua and Felicitas on
6 March, Frances of Rome on 9 March). 365 days were captured live, one
request per day, zero failures.
A separate fixture, not more rows on the existing one. sources.md
already records that the live endpoint has drifted from lectio's
archived 2026-2027 snapshot; merging two versions of one source behind a
single set of expectations would make any future disagreement
unattributable -- calendar or drift, no way to tell. Nothing in the 2038
comparison is checked against the older fixture, and its provenance file
says so, along with the fact that a live capture is not reproducible
byte-for-byte on demand the way a snapshot-derived one is.
338 of 365 days match. 27 differ, every one of them in a named,
already-adjudicated class, none unexplained: 13 the BVM Saturday votive
Mass (M26 shape 1), 7 colour (M21), 2 Judith (M28), 2 Christ the King's
week (M26 shape 2b), 1 Christmas multi-Mass (M27), 1 Perpetua's Common,
1 new. Each was decided in a different year, so 2038 re-confirms them
independently -- the point of a second window is not new rulings but
evidence the old ones are not artefacts of their own year.
Two findings came out of it. Perpetua and Felicitas: missalemeum serves
the Common of Virgins and calls them "Virgins and Martyrs" in its own
oration, where the Missal directs "Missa Me exspectaverunt, de Communi
non Virginum I loco" (scan1:27634-27635). Both Commons share the Introit
Ps 118:95-96, which is exactly why the calendarium qualifies its
direction, and both women were mothers. Verdict colitur; the mechanism
is located on missalemeum's side, not merely asserted. Passion Tuesday:
the Missal prints "Dan. 14, 27 et 28-42" (scan1:11106) and colitur
reproduces that two-part form where missalemeum collapses it to
27-42. Same verses; the convention is deliberate, appearing also in the
Seven Sorrows and the Common of Non-Virgins. Verdict colitur, cosmetic.
Citations are notation-normalised before comparing, as layer 3 already
does: Ecclus/Sir, Joann/John, Luc/Luke, Matth/Matt. Each pair was added
because a real row needed it, and no target contains its own source as a
substring, so the set is idempotent.
Not compared, stated rather than left to be found: commemorations and
observed-identity. That machinery is built around a date-literal
28-entry allow-list specific to 2026-2027, and re-deriving it for a
second year is its own task. 2038 compares rank, colour, Epistle, Gospel.
The extractor's day count was hardcoded to 730, which silently forbade
any other window. It is now a parameter defaulting to 730, so the
existing documented command keeps its guard and a partial fetch still
fails loudly instead of producing a short fixture that passes a
comparison it never ran.
Teeth, by re-running section 6.7's own experiment: corrupting the Common
of Non-Virgins II now reddens four tests, two of them external-oracle,
where the same mutation previously reddened neither oracle layer.
Residual: isidore-of-seville is still unwitnessed and needs 2035 or
2046; gregory-the-great and patrick are never the observed office in any
year 2005-2050, so no fixture in that range can reach them.
Register section 6.8 and 6.9.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
A live-missalemeum sweep over a full liturgical year (2028, 364 days)
returned 333 matching and 31 differing days: 17 already-known or pure
notation, 3 new. All three now adjudicated against the photographic
scans of the 1962 Missal.
The Assumption's Epistle reads "Iudith 13, 22-25; 15, 10" (scan1:35357).
Both engines carried "Judith 13:22-25; 13:15; 13:10" -- a chapter
carry-over defect that re-applied chapter 13 to the second citation and
so invented two verses the Missal never cites. The Seven Sorrows reads
"Iudith 13, 22 et 23-25" (scan1:36938, corroborated at 28468); both
carried "Judith 13:22; 13:25", dropping the range. The third, St Monica,
resolves the other way: the Missal gives 1 Timothy (scan2:32679, heading
and incipit both legible; scan1:29524 agrees) where missalemeum serves
the Common of Holy Women's Proverbs -- colitur is right, no change.
Layer 3 could not have found either citation defect. colitur's data is
bootstrapped from lectio, and lectio is the other side of that
differential, so while both engines produced the identical wrong answer
the comparison held it against itself and reported agreement -- the
shared-lineage blindness CLAUDE.md names, now with a second live witness
beside Holy Thursday's colour. Only an external oracle could see it, and
only outside the committed fixture's own window.
Fixed upstream in lectio, re-bootstrapped here (provenance SHA-256 moved
to 54f6bfc5, verified against the source), fixture regenerated.
The upstream fix inverted layer 3 from blind to load-bearing here:
reverting the Assumption citation now reddens both layers, where before
it would have reddened neither. Verified by mutation, both directions.
Allow-lists:
- C22 closed and removed (128 rows -> 0), not re-adjudicated -- the other
engine was fixed to agree, the same shape as the C2-C5/C7/C9-C13/C21
closures. Its own note had already flagged the Lenten Ember dead-key
bug for upstream; lectio now also fails its build on any unreachable
lectionary key rather than serving a plausible wrong Mass.
- M28 opened (3 rows, verdict colitur), pinning both sides' citation
text rather than the date and diff shape alone, so a different
divergence landing on the same date cannot be swallowed.
- M8's gate widened, expected_rows unchanged at 2: 2027-08-15 carries
both its cause and M28's, and one entry is admitted per day. It stays
under M8, which now requires its own commemoration difference to be
present and admits the citation difference only when it satisfies
M28's two-sided predicate. Neither cause absorbs the other.
layer_m_reason's oracle-row parameter, kept named since M2 closed for
exactly such a future reader, is live again.
Register: docs/research/rules-register.md section 6.6.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
Three Important findings from coordinator review of 8d1eb25, all fixed.
1. C30's own note claimed its 91-row population "is C25's OWN former
population, before this task narrowed it" -- false. Independently
re-derived against the real resolver (pre-fix vs post-fix binary) and
the lectio fixture: only 44 of the 91 rows were ever in C25 (Wed 6/
Thu 19/Fri 19, matching C25's own fix-round-3 breakdown exactly); the
other 47 (all of Monday/Tuesday, plus part of Wednesday/Friday)
previously matched lectio outright -- both engines independently
landing on the same wrong value -- and are newly allow-listed only
because colitur is now right. Rewritten to the same "both engines
silently agreed on the wrong answer" pattern C33/C34 already used.
2. "Diebus ferialibus" is not RG 17(a) -- RG 17(a) states only the
day-identity privilege; the ferial-Mass rubrics are Mass-propers
rubrics, a distinction the register's own §6.3 already drew before
this task's first pass blurred it in code/allow-list comments. A
further slip: C31/C32 called their own rubric "RG 17(a)'s own next/
third sentence" when it is a different rubric block ~230 lines away,
in Holy Family's (not Holy Name's) own feast propers. Fixed the
attribution chain throughout tools/bootstrap_lectionary.ml,
data/ef/expected-divergences.sexp's C29-C34, and (gitignored, outside
this commit) docs/research/rules-register.md -- closed the §6.3 park,
added §6.5 recording all four citations with corrected attribution.
Quotes and line numbers were already right; only the chain of custody
to RG 17(a) was wrong.
3. M26's own 30 rows classify into two nameable shapes, not "three
confirmed shapes" with an unexplained 23-row residue that was in fact
empty: 21 rows are RG 78's own already-documented BVM votive-Mass
gap; 9 rows are a second, distinct gap -- a week whose own Sunday was
displaced by a movable named feast (Trinity->Corpus Christi, "Missa
Dominicae I post Pentecosten"; Christ the King), where the Missal
requires the displaced Sunday's own Mass to keep informing that
week's ferias but step 3 walks back to the displacing feast's citation
instead -- proven directly by colitur's own citation on the Christ-
the-King rows being literally that feast's own Gospel. verdict open
unchanged (not fixed here); the shape is now named instead of buried.
Minors: section count corrected 1458->1456 (four places); "exactly one
candidate, zero ambiguous" corrected to "correctness rests on ordering,
not uniqueness" (2 of 1456 sections genuinely yield two candidates,
Holy Saturday's own Lectio, both years); the stale "nothing in layers
3-5 compares citations" claim corrected (only layer 5 still doesn't);
M18's note corrected (five new entries not six; ~18 of its remaining
352 rows only agree now because of this task's own fixes, not "already"
before it); "five" corrected to "six" otherwise-unoccupied Saturdays in
bootstrap_lectionary.ml; scan2 quotes softened where OCR-garbled.
Also done outside the git-tracked files: the step-4 (Commons) coverage
gap is now recorded in data/ef/expected-divergences-missalemeum.sexp's
own header, not only the commit body and the (gitignored) report.
dune test: 358 tests green. COLITUR_EXHAUSTIVE_SWEEP=1 dune test
--force: 359 tests green, 95.7s.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
Layer 4 (test_oracle.ml) now extracts and compares the Epistle/Gospel
citation for every one of the 730 days in the 2026-2027 fixture, the
same axis Task 8 already added to layer 3. tools/
extract_missalemeum_oracle.py gained a structural citation-span
detector (the first "*...*"-wrapped span under 40 chars containing a
chapter:verse-shaped digit pair), verified exhaustively over all 1 458
Lectio/Evangelium sections. 728 of 730 days are comparable; the 2 that
are not (Good Friday, both years) have no such section in missalemeum's
own JSON at all -- a structural limit on the oracle's own side (M23),
not a colitur gap. 451 of 730 days differ and are all explained across
19 cited entries; 0 unexplained. Chain step 4 (the Commons) has no
layer-4 witness: confirmed empirically (a scratch sweep, not merely
re-asserted from Task 6's own report) that none of the 15 Commons/proper
saints is ever the observed office in this window.
The comparison surfaced three genuine colitur bugs in
data/ef/lectionary.sexp, all fixed at the source in
tools/bootstrap_lectionary.ml:
1. Holy Name of Jesus (ef-holy-name-sunday/ef-holy-name) carried a
mis-derived citation, borrowed by analogy from an unrelated ini
section ("ef-christmas-sunday-0", the Sunday-within-the-Octave's own
Mass) on the wrong assumption the two share a Mass. Disproved by
missalemeum's own extraction for both real Holy Name Sundays in its
window, confirmed against the Missal itself, twice, both scans
(Acts 4:8-12/Luke 2:21, not Gal 4:1-7/Luke 2:33-40).
2. RG 17(a)'s own "diebus ferialibus" rubric (immediately following the
Holy Name heading, both scans) was never implemented: 2-5 January
ferias repeat 1 January's Mass, 7-12 January ferias before Holy
Family Sunday repeat Epiphany's, and Holy Family's own week has a
named formula ("Missa Dominicae Primae post Epiphaniam"). All three
fell to step 3's undifferentiated Sunday walkback instead. Fixed for
three 5-weekday families, deliberately excluding Saturday from all
three -- RG 78's BVM Saturday Office wins there unconditionally,
confirmed against missalemeum's own title on this window's own such
Saturdays.
3. Corpus Christi and Sacred Heart (both real, never-impeded I-class
movable feasts) had no lectionary entry at all. Both engines
independently fell back to Trinity Sunday's own citation and
silently agreed on the wrong answer -- the "Holy Thursday violet in
both" shape CLAUDE.md names for exactly this reason.
Because lectionary.sexp is shared with layer 3 (the lectio differential,
2005-2050), these fixes changed colitur's output for the whole domain,
not only 2026-2027. data/ef/expected-divergences.sexp and
test_differential.ml needed matching updates: C1 narrowed 361->173 and
C25 narrowed 57->13 (rows that now resolve correctly moved to new
entries), C16's note corrected (count unchanged), and six new entries
added (C29-C34, 397 rows total, all verdict colitur). test_lectionary.ml
and test_lectionary_ef.ml's own pins were updated to match (entry count
131->148; one step-3 regression test re-pointed to a date that still
genuinely exercises that step).
One entry, M26 (30 rows, verdict open), is a genuine unfixed gap: colitur's
step-3 "resume the preceding Sunday" fallback is its only ferial-Mass
mechanism, and missalemeum's own selection is more granular in three
confirmed ways (a rotating votive Mass of the BVM, a named weekly
formula for at least one week, and later Time-after-Pentecost weeks this
task's own investigation did not narrow to a single rule) -- the same
"needs a season-keyed selection mechanism, new behaviour not new data"
shape data/ef/expected-divergences.sexp's own C6/C25 and Task 6's own
residual concern already name, out of this task's own scope to build.
dune test: 358 tests green. COLITUR_EXHAUSTIVE_SWEEP=1 dune test
--force: 359 tests green, 89.5s.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
Layer 3 is NOT blind to the ferial resumption rule, unusually for this
project: lectio implements the same rubric independently, so the differential
checks colitur's rule against a second implementation rather than against
silence.
It IS blind to the Commons -- lectio has no such concept -- so chain step 4
rests on layer 4 alone.
Divergence triage, 1 532 of 16 801 days differ (15 269 match exactly),
0 unexplained:
- A genuine colitur bug found and fixed: data/ef/lectionary.sexp carried
lectio's own ini section names verbatim, never translated into the slugs
Temporal_ef actually computes for the identical office. Data the bootstrap
already held (Passiontide both weeks, the Pentecost Ember days, Holy Name
Sunday) was unreachable by chain step 2, silently falling through to a
wrong step-3 answer -- invisible until citation content became comparable.
tools/bootstrap_lectionary.ml gained colitur_keys (rename/widen), a
hand-authored ef-nativity-vigil entry cross-sourced from lectio's own
sanctoral calendar and corroborated by colitur's own (overlay-suppressed)
sanctoral bootstrap of the same source, and a derived ef-holy-name entry
(RG 17(a)'s single Mass heading covers both the Sunday and 2-January
shapes). One guess (giving the fixed Nativity-Octave days Holy Name
Sunday's own citation uniformly) was tried and reverted once measured
against the fixture -- Missal-verified to be right only for the genuine
"Sunday within the Octave" case, wrong whenever the true preceding Sunday
is Christmas Day or Advent IV instead.
- 10 existing/widened Layer C entries (C1/C6/C8/C14/C15/C16/C17/C18 --
C6 and C17 narrowed with the removed population accounted for, not
silently re-absorbed) plus two new ones: C19 (the already-adjudicated
Time-after-Epiphany week-numbering offset, now visible in citation
content), C20 (lectio computes no reading at all for the seven
readingless saints Task 6 gave a Common or proper -- colitur is more
complete, not wrong).
- One entry, C21, is a genuine colitur LOGIC limitation found but not
fixed: Lectionary_ef.readings' step 3 is a single hop to the preceding
Sunday, insufficient for a run of colitur-only fixed Christmastide slugs
whose own preceding Sunday is itself another entry-less fixed slug.
Recorded verdict open (data/ef/expected-divergences-missalemeum.sexp's
own established precedent for this shape), not left silently failing --
fully diagnosed in task-8-report.md, recommended as a dedicated
follow-up task rather than a hasty fix to a shared, multi-round-reviewed
kernel-adjacent function.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
lectio moved 2386a45 -> 3b32c00 (seven EF calendar defects fixed, plus a
sanctoral-generator root-cause fix); the committed fixture predates all
of them. Regenerated with the same command the provenance note already
named (`go run ./cmd/lectio-ef-dump 2005 2050`), read-only against
lectio -- nothing there was touched. New SHA-256 asserted in both the
provenance note and test_differential.ml's fixture_sha256. The dumper's
two new name_en/name_pl columns are kept verbatim (the fixture is meant
to be the exact command's raw output; the comparator already discards
everything past field 7).
Every C-entry's expected_rows was re-derived independently against the
refreshed fixture (a Python re-implementation of diff_fields/
layer_c_reason, cross-checked against the real OCaml comparator's own
failure output), not transcribed from a green run. Nine entries -- C2,
C3, C4, C5, C7, C10, C11, C12, C13 -- now match zero rows and are
closed: sexp row removed, layer_c_reason predicate and its now-dead
helper bindings removed, citation preserved in
docs/research/rules-register.md's new §3d with the specific lectio
commit that fixed each one. C1 (361 -> 368) absorbs C13's former 7 rows
now that lectio's own slug matches there too. C6 (138, unchanged count)
narrows to a slug-only shape now that lectio's rank agrees. C8 (31,
unchanged) survives untouched -- lectio still computes no Rogation days.
C9's old shape ("Joseph observed ON a Lent Sunday") is also closed, but
a narrower, different divergence survived under the same saint's slug: 3
years (2008, 2035, 2046) where Joseph's own congested RG96 walk collides
with the Annunciation's separately-transferred "sedes propria". The old
predicate's broad "any diff involving this slug" match was silently
absorbing both under one citation -- split into a new id, C14, rather
than folded back into C9, since the two are unrelated rules. lectio's
own commit history (09a1444) documents this residual as a gap it
deliberately left unresolved; colitur gives Joseph a real transferred
day either way, which is why C14's verdict stands regardless of a
genuinely open sub-question (recorded in the register, not resolved
here) about which of the two feasts should claim the contested day
first under RG98's "prius impeditum" wording.
Re-triaged the full remaining 4975 raw differences: only 10 distinct
field-diff signatures now, all resolving to Layer A/B noise or the four
surviving citations, 0 unexplained. The crude "Sunday-rank" and "Holy
Thursday" residues the task flagged both fully resolve once the real
Layer A/B machinery runs (season-spelling and week-numbering artifacts,
not substantive divergences) -- see the task report for the derivation.
Teeth proof: perturbing ferial_rank to reproduce C4's old defect made
140 rows reappear as unexplained (the exact prior C4 count), reverted
after capturing the failure message.
277 tests green (dune test) and 278 with COLITUR_EXHAUSTIVE_SWEEP=1 (the
extra case is the 1583-9999 sweep itself).
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
test_oracle.ml (validation layer 4) used to compare commemoration
presence and List.length only -- cardinality, never which candidate is
admitted. A reviewer proved this vacuous by reversing admit's dignity
sort (the engine admitting the worst commemoration, an outright RG 111
violation) and finding every assertion in this file green across all
730 days.
tools/extract_missalemeum_oracle.py now also emits each commemoration's
own missalemeum id (field 9, commemoration_ids), parallel to the
existing title field; fixture regenerated from the same underlying
lectio snapshot (commit d7da4b0, re-verified, first 8 fields
byte-identical), read from a scratch copy so ~/git/projects/lectio was
never touched. SHA-256 pin and provenance updated.
The mapping: colitur identifies a commemoration by slug, missalemeum by
an English title string. No hand-built slug<->title table -- colitur's
own Celebration.t.names already carries the same English text for every
SANCTORAL-origin commemoration (bootstrapped from lectio, verified to
match missalemeum's titles character-for-character). This resolves
identity for every sanctoral-origin commemoration but cannot resolve a
TEMPORAL-origin one (Rite_ef.Temporal_ef never sets a celebration name)
-- that case is a new, distinct outcome (Comm_identity_unresolved),
counted and allow-listed, never silently skipped: 19 of 227
non-empty-commemoration days over 2026-2027.
Two genuine identity mismatches found and adjudicated (new allow-list
entries M15-M17, one is the unresolved bucket): M16, 27 March 2026, the
already-known unimplemented Seven Sorrows of Passion Friday office
(verdict missalemeum); M17, 22 September 2027, the RG 113 same-band
tie-break residual (verdict open, per the sibling admit fix). A new
corroborating check cross-references missalemeum's own id-embedded rank
against colitur's, split by status: Feast-status matches must agree
exactly (none reachable in this 2-year window, checked regardless);
Commemoration_only-status matches either genuinely agree or fit a known,
pre-existing, already-registered convention gap (colitur's bootstrap
rank vs missalemeum's own sentinel) -- not a title-matching defect.
Perturbation test performed and reverted: reversing admit's dignity-
based ordering (compare_precedence's real committed form uses band, not
dignity -- this reproduces the historical defect shape directly) turns
the oracle layer red: "no differences outside the cited allow-list"
fails with an unexplained commemoration-identity-mismatch on 2026-09-23
(colitur admits "St. Thecla" where the rubric and missalemeum both
require "St. Linus"). Reverted; diff against the prior commit confirms
no residue.
CLAUDE.md's "know what each layer cannot see" section updated: the
commemoration-identity gap it documented as open is now closed, with
the mapping's limits and the RG 113 tie-break finding summarised.
271 -> 273 tests (274 with the exhaustive sweep), all green.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
Validation layer 4: an oracle harness against missalemeum (Divinum
Officium data), independent of the lectio bootstrap chain colitur's
own sanctoral data comes from -- the only layer that can catch an
error inherited from that bootstrap, and the only one that can
validate commemorations at all (the lectio differential explicitly
excludes them, per its own header comment).
tools/extract_missalemeum_oracle.py shapes the fixture from lectio's
sources/snapshot.tar.gz outside the test (no JSON library in this
project's frozen deps, same reasoning test_differential.ml's own
fixture already documents). test/fixtures/missalemeum-ef-2026-2027
.txt (730 days, SHA-256 pinned and asserted) + its own .provenance
note record exactly how to regenerate it.
test_oracle.ml compares three axes the oracle actually supports:
rank, colour (SET MEMBERSHIP -- 14 of 730 days carry two colours,
e.g. rose+violet on Gaudete/Laetare, which independently vindicates
this project's own rose reading against lectio's violet-only one,
recorded in the register), and commemoration presence/count. Slug
identity is deliberately out of scope (needs a title->slug mapping,
the data audit's own business, not the automated comparator's).
Of 730 days, 688 matched cleanly outright. The remaining 42 are all
named in data/ef/expected-divergences-missalemeum.sexp (14 cited
entries, M1-M14): most are genuine primary-source-confirmed findings
this task adjudicated and fixed in the two preceding commits (RG 33,
RG 109/111, Holy Thursday's colour); the rest are real, cited,
deferred feature/data gaps (RG 91 entry 27's BVM-Saturday office, RG
110's inseparable Peter/Paul commemoration, four sanctoral entries
missing from lectio's own source) or genuine oracle-side artifacts
-- honestly verdicted against whichever side this task's own
primary-source research actually backs, never defaulted to colitur.
One entry (M13, St Joseph vs the Friday of Passion Week 2027) is
verdict open: adjudicated as unresolved after real search effort,
not guessed past.
The data audit: every sanctoral entry the comparison flagged was
hand-checked against the 1962 calendarium, plus a 20-entry
deterministic random control sample (seed 20260812) drawn
independently of the flagged set. The control sample caught two
entries (benedict, frances-rome) marked Commemoration_only in the
bootstrapped data when the primary calendarium lists them as plain
III-class feasts with their own Office -- traced to lectio's own
source, not fixable here, and reported as a signal (10% of a random
sample) rather than a blanket claim. Coverage recorded honestly in
docs/research/rules-register.md's own three buckets: confirmed by
oracle (200/322), confirmed by hand (23/322, 2 of them wrong),
unverified (115/322) -- the unverified bucket stated explicitly
rather than left implicit.
Harness teeth demonstrated and reverted (not committed): a fixture
rank/colour edit on a previously-clean day fails both the checksum
pin and the no-unexplained-differences assertion independently; an
expected_rows drift on the allow-list fails the citation-count
assertion. Both captured with their exact failure messages, both
reverted before this commit.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
Fix round 1 on Task 15's review, four findings closed.
C1 and C6 previously gated on calendar date alone -- unlike every other
Layer C entry, which also checks the actual colitur slug that won. A
future sanctoral change producing an unrelated celebration with the same
diff shape (e.g. a promoted 29-31 December saint landing on C6's own
[Slug_f; Rank]) would have been silently absorbed under a citation that
has nothing to do with the real cause. Both entries now require, whenever
Slug_f is in the diff set, that colitur's own slug be a member of an
explicit closed list (jan_6_13_slug, nativity_octave_day_slugs) -- the
same style advent_feria_slug already used for C4. Constructed the exact
substitution via a temporary (unshipped) overlay Replace directive
promoting thomas-becket to Class1 Feast White; confirmed the tightened
predicate refuses to absorb it (46 unexplained rows, one per year); reverted.
C10 gained the diff-field-subset restriction every other entry already
had (it previously fired on the two pinned dates regardless of which
fields differed).
Fixed a stale doc comment ("SIX" columns; field has five constructors).
The fixture's provenance note now records its SHA-256, and the suite
asserts it as its own first test case (test_fixture_checksum), so a
hand-edited or partially re-copied fixture fails loudly instead of
silently becoming an unlabelled snapshot. Computed via the system
sha256sum binary through Sys.command plus a redirected-output temp file
-- no new library dependency, not even unix. Constructed a one-byte
fixture edit and confirmed the checksum test fails independently of the
row-comparison test; reverted.
237/237 tests green, clean-build verified.
|
|
|
Validation layer 3 (design spec's five): compares colitur's real day-by-day
EF output against lectio (sibling project, Go), 2005-2050, one line per
civil day. Of 16801 day-pairs, 11206 already agree on the seven leading
columns; the 5595 that don't resolve into exactly 25 distinct field-diff
signatures, all triaged.
Three strictly separate layers, per the controller's ruling (the brief's
single flat allow-list assumed a handful of differences, not 5595):
- Layer A (test_differential.ml, norm_season/norm_slug): vocabulary. An
explicit, closed table of naming synonyms with no liturgical substance
(lectio's easter/christmas vs colitur's paschaltide/christmastide; a
handful of slugs that are two names for the identical office). No
wildcards -- every entry is a literal string pair.
- Layer B (strip_epiphany_index): numbering. The one slug family whose
lectio/colitur index offset is not a constant (Time-after-Epiphany week
numbering, register 3c#5) has its embedded digit stripped to a common
form on both sides before comparing; rank and colour stay fully compared.
- Layer C (data/ef/expected-divergences.sexp): the cited allow-list. Ten
genuine liturgical disagreements, each citing its RG paragraph and
naming which engine is right (always colitur, verified against the
Missal/register, never against lectio's own behaviour). This is the
only layer permitted to cover a difference in rank, colour, or which
celebration is observed. Five extend or restate register 3c's already-
documented divergences (season boundary, Sunday I-class, Advent Ember
ferias, Rogations); five are new, found and adjudicated in this task
(Lent Ember days, the Nativity Octave, Ember-day-vs-saint precedence,
the St Joseph transfer off a Lent Sunday, and the 2011 Sacred Heart /
Precious Blood / Visitation collision). expected_rows on each entry is
an exact regression pin, asserted by the test, not documentation.
13 January (register 6's long-open "Baptism of the Lord" item) is
confirmed empirically fixed already -- Task 11's sanctoral wiring closed
it before this task started -- so it is not allow-listed; the only
residual difference there is the season boundary already covered by C1.
Two stated limits carried from the brief (commemorations are not
comparable; lectio's own EF oracle asserts season only, 2025-2026 only,
so a rank/colour difference is not presumptive evidence against colitur)
plus a third found during this task (the week column is a display
convention on both sides, not a liturgical fact, and is not compared at
all) are documented in the test file's own doc comment.
Fixture: test/fixtures/lectio-ef-2005-2050.txt, committed as plain text
(1.4 MB), generated by lectio commit 2386a45; provenance recorded in the
sibling .provenance file. Colitur's side is recomputed fresh from the
library on every run, through the same Calendar/Rite_ef pipeline
`colitur day` uses, not the compiled binary.
Proved the harness has teeth by two reverted perturbations: a genuine
colour difference injected into a fully-covered fixture row fails the
"no unexplained differences" check with the exact mismatched row printed;
a one-row drift in an allow-list entry's expected_rows fails the count
check independently, showing it is not merely a duplicate of the first
assertion. 236/236 tests green, clean-build verified, deterministic
across OCAMLRUNPARAM=R.
|
